Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Great Christmas Record Odyssey, Ep. CL

Dear God, gang - you might need a stiff drink for this one. Buckle up. . .

Album Title:  Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
Album Artist:  Paul Wing, Walter Schumann


So this one has been tucked away downstairs in our basement storage room (in my 'Christmas Records to be Reviewed' box) for so long I couldn't tell you where or when I picked it up. If I had to wager a guess, I'd say it was most likely from the Dollar Bin section of Radio Wasteland, probably four or five years ago (-ish), and, knowing Brian from 2021 or 2022, it was most definitely snatched up on account of the creepy album artwork.

Call me crazy, but I'm not necessarily cool with how the artist painted Santa and Rudolph on the cover of this thing. Why's Santa trying to mount Rudolph from behind? Santa rides in the sleigh, behind the Reindeer team, this is Christmas 101. And why do they have the same look on their faces? That look a drunk chick at a bar might get from a shady group of dudes who dropped something in her Long Island Iced Tea twenty minutes ago and are waiting for it to take effect before they make their move?

Not appropriate for a children's Christmas album, folks. 

But I digress. Let's talk about this Great Value brand Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer rip-off that we have ourselves today. . .

The opening track on Side A is the famous song that we all know by heart, and, on this album, it's pretty typical, 60's children's fare. Upbeat and bright, with lots backing vocals that sound soooo animated you can practically hear the sugar and booze coming through the mics in the recording booths.

"Rudy's face is funny" gets said a lot in the opening track. I assume this is reference to Rudolph and not some ska-loving, British hooligan in the early 80's. But I could be wrong, I don't know.

Then, without warning, Durin's Bane, the dreaded Balrog that destroyed the Dwarven realm of Moria in the Second Age of Middle Earth, crashes through the front door and starts to bellow out along with the typical children's singers (who I assume all die in the ensuing fires of Mordor.) I'm not sure who pulled the trigger on hiring this guy; he sounds like the bastard offspring ('cause obviously the Balrog was born out of wedlock, you see, as it was consumed in hatred, not love) of Tennessee Ernie Ford and Disney legend Paul Frees. 

Who in their right mind thought a deep baritone voice is appropriate for an upbeat, Christmas song? Like, I get the Grinch theme song - that dude's an asshole - but Rudolph? The plucky, deformed reindeer that saves Christmas? Not really the sort of thing that screams, "Let's add a splash of pure evil to this track."

Following this weird take on the Holiday favorite, we seem to have ourselves. . . a story? It's nothing like the Rankin/Bass offering, it's more like a long-ass poem. Accented by like Loony Tunes/Disney musical accents (you know, like in those old cartoons from the 40's when there's a small animal scurrying and they use flute or xylophone trills, or if it's a big animal they use a timpani or a tuba or some crap), this story follows the classic story that everybody knows. Rudolph is the victim of North Pole hate crimes, he overcomes the racism, somehow lands a job working for Santa (he's probably a DEI hire if we're being completely honest here), the fog rolls in and Santa starts to lose his damn mind, and suddenly Rudolph is like, "hold my beer." And then of course Christmas is saved and everyone forgets all the casual racism that that poor quadruped had to deal with his entire life.

Following this looooong poem (seemingly long as the classic Rankin/Bass cartoon) there's a drunk singing the Frosty the Snowman song. It's the same song that, again, you all know by heart, but instead of, say Jimmy Durante doing his thing, the engineers pulled some hobo out of a gutter out back behind the recording studio and thrust him in front of a microphone in the sound booth. It's not like you have to pay those guys, they'll cut a whole Goddamn album if you promise them a half-pint of Black Velvet and a day-old tuna fish sandwich. This guy sounds like a 60-year-old man who's lived a hard life - like a 1960s Tom Waits but without the world-weariness and introspection.

Side B is the 'leftover' spot on the album - clearly where the company ran out of money for ideas and licensed characters, and just filled in the wax space with 'original' takes on Holiday staples. Remember that Night Before Christmas poem your parents read to you every Christmas Eve? What if you had a bizarre cast of voice actors recite that poem, except they did so to upbeat, children's music? And what if they changed, like, 95% of the poem's words and filled it in with all sorts of Rudolph references that made absolutely zero sense?

That's essentially what you have here. The saving grace here - if there is any - is that it's mercifully short.

Then we have Rudolph II: Big Top Reindeer. It's yet another story about the red nosed reindeer, but this was doesn't rhyme, and it's full of sound effects and voice actors. I'll spare you the details - because most of it doesn't make a whole hell of a lot of sense. Rudolph apparently after saving the day (like we all know well by the classic song), ends up returning to live with his parents (like a loser.) These days Santa is getting in the habit of employing Rudolph's bright nose for daily chores around the house, such as using the fabled hero as a reading light so Saint Nick can read all the Christmas letters from the world's children. So Santa dials Rudolph up on a rotary phone (you can tell by the sound effects guys, I'm not trying to be witty here), and gets that DEI hire up to his office to do chump duty. What follows is some sorta plot like that involves a circus (seriously), a bunch of carnie workers and sideshow freaks being pulled out of the darkest corners of society and paraded about for underprivileged children. And it gets weirder from there, but I'll spare you the details.

Guys, I've reviewed a lot of Christmas albums that have been marketed for children in the past, but this one might be one of the most obnoxious I've ever been subjected to. It gets a couple bonus points because the production value is somewhat acceptable - they've got an entire library of sound effects at their disposal, the music used in the songs and as accents during the 'stories' is appropriate and mixed well, and the voice actors (with the exception of the Balrog and the back-alley drunk, of course) aren't horrible. 

What I can't overlook are the weird 'liberties' they took with such classic content. You know what it's like?Remember how like back in the day when you had to write a 5-page book report on a book you only read the first six pages of, so you just kinda stretched those six pages you did read and exaggerate their importance? You repeated yourself constantly, contradicted yourself, glossed over the details, and added in a crap-load of nonsense in order to use up all of the required pages? And your teacher ultimately handed it back at the end of class with a 'D-' and a 'Please see me after class' scrawled in red marker across the top?

This is what we have here, just in music form.

VERDICT:  3/10 - Seriously? (A fever dream of a children's Christmas album, crammed with some of the most bizarre content you'll experience this Holiday season.)

- SHELVED -

- Brian

No comments: